“Pre-Revolutionary Profiles: your assigned Nationality and Class”

NAME: Dorotea Montalbán López

BIRTHDATE: 13/02/1895


CLASS: Working class


PROFESSION: I work in the textile industry.


PROFILE PICTURE:



MY DAILY LIFE: My day a day is not that amazing. I work almost all week exhausting hours in making clothes for people and the money I earn isn't proportional to the work I do. I think my life could be better.


POLITICAL CONTEXT: The context in which I live is authoritarian. I don't agree on it because people like us aren't taken into account. We are also treated not in a proper way, we work a lot and we aren't paid that much.


ECONOMIC CONTEXT: As I can see, Mexico is developing, talking about implementing railroads, etc. Unfortunately that works better for the minority rather than us. Obviously I don't agree with this system because it doesn't benefit me as much as it does for people from a higher social class.


SOCIAL CONTEXT: The social context in which I live protects individual rights for the minority of the people. I really disagree on this one because workers are forced to works long shifts or extra time without being paid more. Basically our rights are not acknowledged.


PREDICTION FOR THE FUTURE: I think the future of our country would be negative, since the majority are lower class and that's were the main problems are focused on. If Mexico keeps this systems, I think there would not be progress. I also believe that Mexico is being affected economically because it is being based on foreign companies, instead of local.


CHANGE or CONTINUITY: I personally want changes in all the systems, so that things can be different for workers. I think I would be more Liberal since I want to have different systems as well as for my rights to be acknowledge, be taken into account and be equality.


MOST PREFERRED LEADER: I support and agree the most with Emiliano Zapata. I support him because he wants to help us (workers) by distributing more equitably the land. I also think that he could help us change Mexico since the majority ( the people that are suffering ) supports him, and that could lead us to a Revolution.


SECOND CHOICE LEADER: My second choice leader would be Francisco I. Madero. I support some of his ideals. I agree with him because he wants to protect individual rights and defend workers' labor guarantees, which would benefit me. But I don't agree 100% with his form of government.


LEAST PREFERRED LEADER: I definitely oppose with Porfirio Diaz's ideas. I basically disagree that all the economic benefits are for the elite and that he has a more conservative form of government.



“WE NEED A REVOLUTION BECAUSE THE MAJORITY OF THE COUNTRY IS LIVING IN BAD CONDITION AND WITH UNACKNOWLEDGED RIGHTS” 








MEXICAN ELITES:


NAME : Alejandro García Márquez


I agree with him that elites are more protected than the low class and that everyone should have the same protection. As he also mentions and I think he is right, Porfirio has developed economically the country, but it is not equally for everyone . 



https://b01659062.blogspot.com/2021/01/pre-revolutionary-profiles-elites-mexico.html?

showComment=1611861183731#c4666263713744163518

MEXICAN DISSIDENT ELITES:


NAME: Fernando Olagaray


Similarities, because although hi is part of the elite, he also thinks that is unfair the situation in which the majority of the people that doesn't have his status are.


We both agree that we want a democratic system, and that the elites have more rights than us.


https://b01659498.blogspot.com/2021/01/pre-revolutionary-profiles-mexican.html


RUSSIAN ELITES:


NAME: Vladimir Ivanov 


I totally disagree with him. He only cares about himself and all the privileges he has, and don't even matter on how lower classes live. 


He also wants to keep this system just because he is benefited by it, which I disagree. 


https://b01659312.blogspot.com/2021/01/pre-revolutionary-profiles-russian.html

RUSSIAN DISSIDENT ELITES:


NAME : Camille Alekseeva


Similarities, because even thought we are from different countries and social classes, we both agree that is unfair that lower classes don't have the same opportunities as elites. 

https://b01659136.blogspot.com/2021/01/pre-revolutionary-profiles-russian.html?showComment=1611858634925#c2855335297957303000

RUSSIAN WORKING CLASS:


NAME: Khristeen Karenina


Although we are from different countries, we belong to the same social class, so I agree with her that the

way of ruling only benefits rich people. 


https://b01659078.blogspot.com/2021/01/pre-revolutionary-profiles-working.html?showComment=1611860534052#c4617663799267853212




Comentarios

  1. Your ideas are so wrong,I totally disagree. ¡¡Elites should have the power always!! ¡¡We deserve being benefited from everything !!

    ResponderBorrar
  2. I like the majority of your ideas, but I prefer the capitalist system of Madero because with that everyone gets what they deserve. Very good!

    ResponderBorrar
    Respuestas
    1. Oh that's fine. I think no one can agree 100% with everything, right?

      Borrar
  3. I think some of your ideas are great, so the working class can live in better conditions. But I would consider Madero the best option, so elites can stay in good conditions too and they are not that affected. Wish you luck from Russia!
    I invite you to my profile so you can see the perspective of an elite that is not that selfish as others.
    https://b01659168.blogspot.com/2021/01/pre-revolutionary-profiles-dissident.html

    ResponderBorrar
  4. HI Dorotea, greetings from russia, I hate that you are treated this way, I see why you chose Zapata, as a dissident elite, he's not the best option, but I hope it all works out.
    xoxo

    ResponderBorrar
  5. Hello Dorotea, so sad to hear what you are going through. I have a similar ideas to yours. But I prefer Madero's ideas rather than Zapata's, but I support you.

    ResponderBorrar
  6. I totally disagree with you. You cannot take OUR lands just because you don't have enough. Elites will always have the power and be superior. You won't change that.

    I invite you to check my profile so you can see the damage you are doing to upper class people.
    https://b01659157.blogspot.com

    ResponderBorrar

Publicar un comentario